I have some forwarders setup on my server that go from [email protected] to [email protected]. When mail comes in from [email protected] (or AOL) to [email protected] and then forwarded, the Comcast email servers reject it with dmarc policy. I know this is because the from address is yahoo and yahoo tells Comcast to reject it if it did not come from a yahoo server. Is there a work around for this? Could I change the forwarder to change the sender address to the forwarder address for only @yahoo etc addresses? The sender address would be unknown. Yahoo stinks with this policy of theirs.
DMARC shouould not fail (SPF must fail but the DKIM-check should work). http://dmarc.org/faq.html#r_1